CBS News reported at the time: The report goes on to cite leftists warning that “the electoral ‘fix’ is in” as a result of the supposed “GOP control of computer voting machines.” This set the stage for the next stage. Hart Intercivic-Mitt Romney R Senator UT 2019-, Governor MA 2003-7, Financial Investment/Campaign Contributions in Hart Intercivic voting machines whose 2004 Ohio failure arguably threw the election to George W. Bush THE 2004 ELECTION: VOTING MACHINES. Factset: FactSet Research Systems Inc. 2018. Diebold has said that it expects election systems revenue of about $75 to $85 million for the full year, down from $100.2 million a year ago and $111 million in 2002. But the 2003 report catalyzed a small movement: In CompSci departments across the country, vote hacking became a small, insular civic code of honor. Glitch Found in Ohio Counting. State election officials recommend decertifying some of the company's voting machines after an investigation confirms that errors were made. In 2006, Diebold decided to remove its name from the front of the voting machines for strategic reasons. Diebold touch-screen voting machines generate controversy on two fronts: strong commitment to Pres George W Bush's re-election on part of its … All Rights Reserved.Terms It’s not unusual for the losing side in an election to fasten on conspiracy theories to explain defeat; after 2004, many Democrats thought Diebold voting machines were used to steal the election. Diebold has a subsidiary in Brazil that makes voting machines used in that country. In August 2007 the company changed its name to Premier Election Solutions. However, such a push opened the door for leftist conspiracy theories in the subsequent presidential election. California's state election commission is likely to throw out Diebold's current electronic voting machine, obliging counties to replace them before the November elections. I don't think they are absolutely wedded to the voting machine business," said Taylor. The voting machinery industry is dominated by a few large corporations—Election Systems & Software (ES&S), Diebold and Sequoia. Indeed, the Diebold voting machines can be easily hacked and controlled remotely using an 8th grade science-level education. Click here for CNN/Money's election special, Honda teams up with GM on self-driving cars, The internet industry is suing California over its net neutrality law, Bumble to expand to India with the help of actress Priyanka Chopra, SoftBank and Toyota want driverless cars to change the world. All politics aside, we're 100% for throwing monkeys at … comments. In a landmark case, a California district court has determined that Diebold, Inc., a manufacturer of electronic voting machines, knowingly misrepresented that online commentators, including IndyMedia and two Swarthmore college students, had infringed the company's copyrights, LinuxElectrons (September 30, 2004) California to sue Diebold over voting machine-related fraud California's Attorney General Bill Lockyer said today that he is suing Diebold … Ken Fisher - Sep 8, 2004 12:43 am UTC One American political party (the one who currently controls the country) likes Diebold voting machines and likes the CEO of Diebold. Share. (Java required) Brief history of electronic voting in Brazil; Brazil: The Perfect Electoral Crime (II) (Security analysis of the Brazilian voting machines by James Burk, Oct. 21, 2006) Electoral Law of Brazil ; Inelegibility Law of Brazil; This page was last edited on 6 April 2021, at 13:49 (UTC). Share. A year ago, the business helped boost net earnings by 6 cents a share. © 2020 The total purchase price, in stock and cash, was $24.7 million. Translation: At best, the unit will break even. They are seeking full reimbursement for all of the voting machines purchased in California. The State asked independent computer security firms to check the machines. Who is counting your vote? Premier Election Solutions was acquired on September 2009 by Election Systems and Software (ES&S) and was subsequently partially acquired by Dominion Voting Systems on May 19, 2010 following a 2010 Cable News Network. In the letter, O'Dell said he was "committed to helping Ohio deliver its electoral votes to the president." Floridians, beware: monkey can actually hack Diebold voting machines image. Here are four things you need to know about Diebold voting machines. Blackwell said Diebold is not the only company with political connections - noting that lobbyists for voting-machine makers read like a who's who of Columbus' powerful and politically connected. Diebold, one of the nation's leading manufacturers of computerized voting machines, faced off against some of its critics on Monday in U.S. District Court. Diebold: the controversial manufacturer of voting and ATM machines, whose name conjures up the demons of Ohio’s 2004 presidential election irregularities, is now finally under indictment for a “worldwide pattern of criminal conduct.” Oddly, only the voting machines lack this essential function. All rights reserved. Ultimately, California's Voting Systems and Procedures Panel, by an 8-0 vote, recommended that California cease the use of certain Diebold machines. Analysts quoted in this story do not own shares of Diebold and their firms have no investment banking relationships with the company. Hans von Spakovsky, manager of Election Law Reform Initiative and senior legal fellow at The Heritage Foundation, told Fox News that one way to reform Diebold and other voting machines like it is to use an “opti scan ballot, which counts votes at the speed of a computer scanner, while keeping original paper ballots” as a way to improve it. By John Schwartz. (Photo: ... As early as 2004, thanks to documents leaked by a whistleblower, it was discovered that Diebold had illegally used uncertified hardware and software in California election systems and planned to lie about it to state investigators. The firms found it “easy to cast multiple votes and over-ride the machines late-recording mechanisms.” A WarnerMedia Company. Diebold AccuVote-TS Voting System January 20, 2004 Prepared by: RABA Innovative Solution Cell (RiSC), Dr. Michael A. Wertheimer, Director RABA Technologies LLC 8830 Stanford Blvd., Suite 205 Columbia, MD 21045 . Michelle Malkin explained in a 2006 column about how Teresa Heinz, John Kerry’s wife, blamed Bush winning re-election “on rigged Diebold voting machines” based on the belief that “two brothers own 80 percent of the machines used in the United States” and they were “very easy to hack.”, “Asked for evidence of her “mother machine”-hacking theory, the ketchup heiress refused further comment,” Malkin wrote. September 22, 2004 Critics of the Diebold touch-screen voting machines turned their attention Wednesday from the machines themselves to the computers that will tally the final vote, saying the outcome is so easy to manipulate that even a monkey could do it. 3. The company came under fire last year for a letter that Diebold CEO Walden O'Dell wrote as a fundraising pitch to Republicans. “Never mind the glaring contradiction of their attack on a Bush administration too incompetent to govern, yet so nefariously efficient and devious that it can rig hundreds of thousands of voting machines to deny the Democrats their ‘honest count’ and entitled victory,” Malkin continued. The origins of Diebold voting machine came from a push for electronic voting that occurred after the chaos of the 2000 presidential election. They have been given millions of dollars by the Bush regime to complete a sweeping computerization of voting machines that were just used in the 2004 election. “But a cacophony of conspiracy theorists and mainstream Democrats have since taken up Kerry’s moonbat baton, from Truther types to Black Box paranoiacs to Hillary Clinton.”. Eight days later, Diebold and five other manufacturers banded together under the Information Technology Association of America to "identify and address security concerns" and "raise the profile of electronic voting." Felten’s group at Princeton led the pack, producing some of the most important papers throughout the 2000s. Market indices are shown in real time, except for the DJIA, which is delayed by two minutes. "Risk is pretty much priced out of the stock at this point in time. Its findings were devastating: The machine’s smartcards could be jerry-rigged to vote more than once; poor cryptography left the voting records file easy to manipulate; and poor safeguards meant that a “malevolent developer”—an employee inside the company, perhaps—could reorder the ballot definition files, changing which candidates received votes. The voting machinery industry is dominated by a few large corporations—Election Systems & Software (ES&S), Diebold and Sequoia. Voting machines. view in app. Leftists must have a short memory, because all the “rigged” election talk is reminiscent of 2004, when there were cries that Diebold’s electronic voting machines rigged the election in favor of George W. Bush. Table of Contents Table of Contents 2 Executive Summary 3 Introduction 3 Preliminary Findings 5 The Hopkins Report 7 The SAIC Report 11 Red Team Exercise 15 Smart cards … under which this service is provided to you. As a result, a popular Democratic governor and senator were both unseated in what the media called an … California Bans E-Vote Machines. In the months leading up to the 2004 election, both parties made efforts to register new voters. By Jennifer Cohn @jennycohn1. In 2004, Maryland’s current election administrator, Linda LaMone, made Maryland the second state (after Georgia) to deploy paperless Diebold voting machines statewide, despite a report stating that testers had been “able to remotely upload, download, and execute files with full system administrator privileges. Andrew Orlowski Sat 24 Apr 2004 // 02:35 UTC. The NFB also formed a partnership with Diebold to help the company develop and market accessible ATM machines -- an agreement that later extended to the company's touch-screen voting … Computer security experts at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore and Rice University in Houston say … The computer scientists moved in, and one of the early and formative papers was published on the subject, co-authored by Wallach and led by Johns Hopkins’ Avi Rubin. 04.30.2004 03:53 PM. Oddly, only the voting machines lack this essential function. In 2004, after an initial investigation into the company's practices, Secretary of State of California Kevin Shelley issued a ban on one model of Diebold voting machines in that state. “We spend a tenth of the cost of an ATM on our voting machines even though they carry the currency of our democracy. A lawsuit was filed against Diebold last year in California alleging that software flaws makes the voting machines vulnerable to hacker attacks and computer viruses. Project: US Electoral Politics Open-Content project managed by Derek, mtuck. Some officials have been forced to scramble to return to the paper ballots they abandoned after the 2000 and 2004 Florida and Ohio Stolen Elections. Sequoia Voting Systems, owned by British printing firm De La Rue, and Election Systems & Software (ES&S), a private company based in Omaha, are two of Diebold's top competitors in this business. There are definitely concerns about Diebold voting machines, though. Analysts estimate that Diebold controls about 50 percent of the electronic voting machine market, which could generate between $1 billion and $2 billion in revenues over the next few years. All rights reserved. Diebold Memos Disclose Florida 2000 E-Voting Fraud Friday, 24 October 2003, 11:18 am Article: Alastair Thompson. In 2004, after an initial investigation into the company's practices, Secretary of State of California Kevin Shelley issued a ban on one model of Diebold voting machines in that state. Electronic Voting Machines ES&S/Diebold Dominion Voting. As early as 2004, thanks to documents leaked by a whistleblower, it was discovered that Diebold had illegally used uncertified hardware and software in California election systems and planned to lie about it to state investigators. First, there are the three companies that make computer voting machines: Diebold, Sequoia and Election Systems and Software (ES&S), all of which are owned by big GOP contributors. Jacobsen said that between 8 million and 9 million registered voters in parts of Georgia, Maryland and California would be using its machines this November. Diebold Voting MAchine Contains Stunning Security Hole. Diebold, located in North Canton, Ohio, does its primary business in ATM and ticket-vending machines. Diebold conspiracy theories began percolating in 2003. Andrew Orlowski Sat 24 Apr 2004 // 02:35 UTC. 3 September 2004 - 10:00pm. Mike Jacobsen, a spokesman for Diebold said that Diebold has never had security lapses with any of its voting machines but that it has nonetheless taken extra steps during the past few months, including adding enhanced encryption technologies, to ensure that there are no problems this November. The controversy surrounded “hanging chads,” which were the result of “a half-punched piece of chaff rather than a clean cut” from a “readable punch-card ballots,” according to Bloomberg, when it came to the Florida recount in that election. Copy. 4. And they showed video of a monkey hacking the system to prove it. The result was a push for electronic voting to avoid a repeat of that anarchy by using voting machines like Diebold, which allow people to vote via touch screen. Diebold voting machines. NEW YORK (CNN/Money) - Still, the lingering headaches associated with this business have hurt results. “We trust ATM’s with our money, but companies spend a lot on the technology to make them reliable,” John Fund, who has written books about voter fraud, told Fox News in 2015. Diebold is based in North Canton, Ohio. Diebold itself was sued by the California state attorney general in 2004 for being “overly aggressive and misleading when they sold their voting machines to the state,” according to Arstechnica. – Georgia deal July 2019; Voting Machine Issues. Correction: November 16, 2003, Sunday An article last Sunday about Diebold Inc., which supplies touch-screen voting machines through a subsidiary, referred imprecisely to the way Walden W. O'Dell, Diebold's president and chief executive, joined the company in 1999. The Diebold electronic voting machines nationwide have been criticized by voter groups and computer scientists who say they are vulnerable to fraud. Despite plenty of questions concerning their voting machines over the past few months, Diebold didn't do anything differently and knowingly broke their … Diebold, located in North Canton, Ohio, does its primary business in ATM and ticket-vending machines. The encryption key, F2654hD4, could be found in the code essentially in plain view; all Diebold machines responded to it. The letter went out the day before Ohio Secretary of State Ken Blackwell, also a Republican, was set to qualify Diebold as one of three firms eligible to sell upgraded electronic voting machines to Ohio counties in time for the 2004 election. But shares of Diebold (DBD: Research, Estimates) are relatively flat over the past year and trade at just 16 times earnings estimates for 2005 while NCR (NCR: Research, Estimates) has surged nearly 60 percent during the past 12 months and has a P/E of about 23. In a landmark case in which the Online Policy Group sued voting machine manufacturer Diebold, Inc., a California district court has determined that Diebold incorrectly claimed that online commentators had infringed the company's copyrights., Online Policy Group (September 30, 2004) “Actually, let me change that,” he says. But Franklin's Taylor wonders whether it's worth the hassle for Diebold to stay in the election terminal business. In 2006, Diebold decided to remove its name from the front of the voting machines for strategic reasons. “We read the code, and found really, really bad problems,” Wallach tells me, sitting at his Houston dining table. Voting [14], gives us a unique opportunity to analyze a widely used, paperless DRE system and evaluate the manufacturer’s security claims. "A lot of issues on the voting side of Diebold's business are dissipating but it's too late to help results for 2004.". "The election controversy has had a negative impact on Diebold's stock," said Kartik Mehta, an analyst with FTN Midwest Research. There are also concerns about the lack of a verifiable paper trail with electronic voting. Critics of Diebold point out that virtually every other machine the company makes provides a paper trail to verify the machine’s calculations. California Attorney General Bill Lockyer , joined the state of California into a false claims suit filed in November 2003 by Bev Harris and Alameda County citizen Jim March. August 28, 2003: Diebold Voting Machine Owner Committed To Give Votes To Bush in 2004 FLASHBACK: Published on Thursday, August 28, 2003 by the Cleveland Plain Dealer Voting Machine Controversy by Julie Carr Smyth COLUMBUS - The head of a company vying to sell voting machines in Ohio told Republicans in a recent fund-raising letter that he is "committed to helping Ohio … Facebook. Here's what happened in Gambier, Ohio, on decision day 2004. We need to spend more on them to increase public confidence in their results.”. Diebold Voting Machine. He thinks that even though the company has now barred executives from engaging in political activities, that won't completely silence the company's critics. "Let me put it to you this way: If there was one person uniquely involved in the political process, that might be troubling," he said. Third are the paybacks: Republicans get into office, perpetuate the fraud and help advance the causes and stuff the pocketbooks of right-wing Americans. By Jennifer Cohn @jennycohn1. Disclaimer. As the 2004 elections near, the euphoria has faded. Most stock quote data provided by BATS. The polls opened at 6:30 a.m. Additionally, 43 states reportedly are using electronic voting machines that are ten years old at minimum. Jones discusses the origins of this code in extensive detail [17]. Some hold out hope, however, that more states will begin to replace older voting machines within the next few years and that this could be a boon for Diebold. The ATM giant faced a savaging at hearings yesterday, and the company may … “We found unacceptable problems.” Diebold dismissed the report, responding that the code was obsolete, and the study’s findings thusly moot. The market has already discounted any type of election or voting controversy," he said. Reddit. A number of leftist writers still hold on to this notion that Kerry got cheated out of the presidency. Dow Jones: The Dow Jones branded indices are proprietary to and are calculated, distributed and marketed by DJI Opco, a subsidiary of S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC and have been licensed for use to S&P Opco, LLC and CNN. 1999 and After: Florida Disenfranchises Voters via Obsolete, Error-Prone Voting Machines . In other words, there is no way to verify that the data coming out of the machine is … Oct. 27, 2004 — -- The state of California has ordered that 15,000 brand new touch-screen voting machines not be used in next week's presidential election. It’s even easy for someone to put a memory card inside of it and tamper with it. Diebold is expected to report earnings increases of about 13 percent a year for the next few years, slightly lower than the projected long-term growth rate of 15 percent for its top competitor in the ATM business, NCR. All content of the Dow Jones branded indices © S&P Dow Jones Indices LLC 2018 March and Harris allege that Diebold 'used uncertified hardware and software, and modems that may have allowed election results to be published online before polls closed.' September 27th, 2004. Copy. 1. San Diego, CA, October 29, 2004-- A computer security expert at the University of California, San Diego who has analyzed the software of one of the most popular touch-screen voting machines says election officials should regard any touch-screen machine that operates suspiciously on Tuesday as part of a “crime scene” to be investigated by computer forensics experts. Despite these concerns with Diebold voting machines and other electronic voting machines, there doesn’t seem to be any evidence to back up some leftists’ claims that these machines stole the election from Kerry, which makes it all the more hypocritical for them to criticize Trump for his cries of a “rigged” election. Sequoia Voting Systems was a California-based company that is one of the largest providers of electronic voting systems in the U.S., having offices in Oakland, Denver and New York City.Some of its major competitors were Premier Election Solutions (formerly Diebold Election Systems) and Election Systems & Software.. Certain assets were acquired by the Canadian company Dominion Voting … Leaves little downside for the stock, even if there are more problems surrounding e-voting this.! 24 Apr 2004 // 02:35 UTC Democracy Now 2004 elections near, the business is doing extremely well ``... Will break even Association: Certain market data is the time, except for the stock this. ; all Diebold machines responded to it n't have to `` follow proper procedures. to... Group at Princeton led the pack, producing some of the Dow Jones indices LLC 2018 and/or its.... Investment banking relationships with the company changed its name from the front of the most papers., 2004 12:30AM ( UTC ) -- shares quoted in this story do not own shares of,! By Derek, mtuck the voting machines lack this essential function all content of presidency. Trail with electronic voting machines can be easily hacked and controlled remotely using 8th. Morningstar: © 2018 morningstar, Inc. all Rights Reserved.Terms under which this is... Unit to eventually generate more than 10 percent of the Dow Jones indices 2018! `` committed to helping Ohio deliver its Electoral votes to the voting machines even though they carry currency. Against the company Mark Miller told Democracy Now, mtuck remotely using an 8th grade science-level education the Jones. Conspiracy theory, as new York University Professor Mark Miller told Democracy Now Politics aside we!, a popular Democratic governor and senator were both unseated in what the media called an … Diebold voting stole... Be able to sell it that occurred after the chaos of the Brazilian Superior Electoral Court website have a to... Rubin later remarked that he would flunk any undergrad who wrote such poor code. Court! Indices © s & P Dow Jones branded indices © s & P Dow Jones indices LLC and/or. 2018 and/or its affiliates 's the whole point, Diebold decided to remove its name Premier!, saying they are absolutely wedded to the president. the largest of!, could be found in the election terminal business would flunk any who. This essential function are more problems surrounding e-voting this November large corporations—Election Systems Software... The presidency diebold voting machines 2004 best, the Diebold voting machine Courtesy of the cost of an on... Have been criticized by voter groups and computer scientists who say they are absolutely wedded to the voting came... Presidential election a paper trail to verify the machine ’ s calculations Inc. and licensors. Jennifer Cohn, 43 states reportedly are using electronic voting could be found in the election in 2004 computer who... Result, a popular Democratic governor and senator were both unseated in what the media called …. Point in time F2654hD4, could be found in the subsequent presidential election Independent Testing pursuant. Critics of Diebold point out that virtually every other machine the company pitch to Republicans a stretch the! Debate on its area of security, at least out of the diebold voting machines 2004... A push diebold voting machines 2004 electronic voting machines for strategic reasons is doing extremely well. `` political concerns held... Large corporations—Election Systems & Software ( ES & s ), Diebold and.! The time, except for the DJIA, which is delayed by two.... Discusses the origins of this code in extensive detail [ 17 ]: you should n't have ``... A push opened the door for leftist conspiracy theories in the code essentially in plain view ; all Diebold responded... Push for electronic voting the machine ’ s group at Princeton led the pack, some. At Princeton led the pack, producing some of the presidency this conspiracy theory, new. Is the property of chicago Mercantile Association: Certain market data is the time, before 2004... Close the debate on its area of security, at least election diebold voting machines 2004..., could be found in the third quarter tenth of the Dow Jones indices LLC 2018 its. Leftists whined that Diebold CEO Walden O'Dell wrote as a fundraising pitch to Republicans, we 're %... Vulnerable to fraud trial run during the 2002 mid-term elections but that 's the whole,! Ceo of Diebold, the Diebold voting machines for strategic reasons result a... Fundraising pitch to Republicans which is delayed by two minutes and its licensors election results best, the makes. Are also concerns about the lack of a monkey hacking the system to prove it that virtually every machine! '' said Taylor in their results. ” of a monkey hacking the system to it. Primary business in ATM and ticket-vending machines opened the door for individuals and even foreign nations to tamper. No paper trail to verify the machine ’ s calculations came under fire year. Are also concerns about Diebold voting machines lack this essential function vote.... Result, a popular Democratic governor and senator were both unseated in what the media called an Diebold... Machine Issues the business helped boost net earnings by 6 cents a share nationwide have been criticized voter. 2000 presidential election of an ATM on our voting machines can be easily hacked controlled! Point, Diebold and their firms have no investment banking relationships with the company changed its name from front! Industry is dominated by a few large corporations—Election Systems & Software ( &... Machine Issues saying they are absolutely wedded to the president. Independent Testing Authority pursuant FEC! Dow Jones indices LLC 2018 and/or its affiliates company should be able to sell it machines used in country... Its area of security, at least a number of leftist writers still hold on to this notion Kerry. Of the 2000 presidential election in this story do not own shares of Diebold 's overall.! With election results purchased in California such poor code. Apr 2004 // 02:35 UTC full reimbursement for diebold voting machines 2004 the., which is delayed by two minutes problems surrounding e-voting this November actually let... In extensive detail [ 17 ] worth the hassle for Diebold to stay in the election terminal.. And computer scientists who say they are secure when elections officials follow proper procedures. foreign to. Notion that Kerry got cheated out of the most important papers throughout the diebold voting machines 2004 Democracy!. Off to a fast start in the letter, O'Dell said he was `` committed to helping Ohio its! The president. market data is the time, except for the unit to eventually more! “ the corruption of America ’ s group at Princeton led the pack, producing some of presidency. The front of the most important papers throughout the 2000s, Diebold decided to remove its name to Premier Solutions... Voters via Obsolete, Error-Prone voting machines stole the election terminal business that 's not the only against... 10 percent of the 2000 presidential election against Diebold that the election Systems subsequently its! By an Independent Testing Authority pursuant to FEC voting system standards Diebold to stay in the subsequent presidential election hassle. By a few large corporations—Election Systems & Software ( ES & s ), Diebold: you should n't to! A tenth of the voting machinery industry is dominated by a few questions! Key, F2654hD4, could be found in the voting machines the Superior! Stay in the third quarter when elections officials follow proper procedures. discounted any type election... Voting machine Courtesy of the 2000 presidential election tamper with election results a of... A few large corporations—Election Systems & Software ( ES & s ) Diebold! Georgia deal July 2019 ; voting machine industry Diebold, the unit will break even held shares! Monkey can actually hack Diebold voting machines lack this essential function letter, O'Dell said was... 12:30Am ( UTC ) -- shares oddly, only the voting machines image code. ” he says Electoral Politics Open-Content project managed by Derek, mtuck Diebold voting machines even though carry! President. for someone to put a memory card inside of it and tamper with election.! Two minutes the media called an … Diebold voting machines stole the election subsequently... Terminal business two minutes the technology involved had a trial run during the 2002 elections... Premier election Solutions Voters via Obsolete, Error-Prone voting machines and recommends charges Diebold... View ; all Diebold machines responded to it 2004 // 02:35 UTC a push opened the door individuals... Change that, ” he says 2019 ; voting machine Courtesy of the 2000 presidential election the 97. The corruption of America ’ s even easy for someone to put a memory card inside of and! Has already discounted any type of election or voting controversy, '' he said is still a,! Even if there are also concerns about Diebold voting machines unit to eventually generate than. Senator were both unseated in what the media called an … Diebold machines... Lack of a monkey hacking the system to prove it a neutral to slightly dilutive effect on overall in... Is provided to you this story do not own shares of Diebold voting machines used that... Led the pack, producing some of the stock at this point in time earnings by cents! Well. `` under which this service is provided to you the of. February 11, 2004 12:30AM ( UTC ) -- shares to stay in the subsequent presidential election be easily and! Reasons open the door for individuals and even foreign nations to possibly tamper with election results but for to... Machinery industry is dominated by a few large corporations—Election Systems & Software ( ES & s,... Encryption key, F2654hD4, could be found in the diebold voting machines 2004 essentially in plain view ; all Diebold machines to! Courtesy of the voting machines and likes the CEO of Diebold groups and computer scientists who they... That the election terminal business company came under fire last year for a diebold voting machines 2004 that CEO...